Skip to content
CE-403 · Structural Analysis-I/Quick Revision Short Notes

Structural Analysis-I (CE-403) - Unit 1 Short Notes

UNIT 1: FUNDAMENTAL CONCEPTS, THEOREMS, INFLUENCE LINES & SPECIAL STRUCTURES


1.0 FUNDAMENTAL CONCEPTS & STRUCTURAL CLASSIFICATION

1.1 Degree of Indeterminacy

  • Static Indeterminacy (Ns): Number of extra equilibrium equations needed to solve for all reactions & internal forces.

    • External (Ns,ext): Extra reactions beyond 3 for plane structures.

    • Internal (Ns,int): Extra member forces beyond the number of equilibrium equations per joint.

    • Total: $$\displaystyle N_s = N_{s,ext} + N_{s,int} $$

  • Kinematic Indeterminacy (Nk): Number of independent joint displacements (rotations & translations) possible.

  • Calculation (Plane Frames/Trusses, Axial Deformations Neglected):

    • Truss: $$\displaystyle N_s = r - 3 $$ (r = external reactions). For internal: $$\displaystyle N_s = m - 2j $$ (m=members, j=joints excluding supports). Total $$\displaystyle N_s = (r-3) + (m-2j) $$.

    • Frame: $$\displaystyle N_s = (3m + r) - (3j + 3) $$ for general plane frames. (m=members, j=joints, r=reactions).

  • Stability Condition: For a stable isostatic structure: $$\displaystyle N_s = N_k = 0 $$.

[!TIP] Exam Focus: Calculating Ns for given frames/trusses is a very frequent question. Remember to count correctly for rigid joints (each adds 3 unknowns but only 3 eqns per joint, so often Nk=3 for a rigid joint in a frame).

1.2 Stability of Structures

  • Mechanical Stability: Ability of a structure to maintain its geometry under load without mechanism formation.

  • Conditions:

    • Pin-Jointed (Truss): $m \geq 2j - 3$ for stability. If $$\displaystyle m = 2j - 3 $$, it's isostatic & stable.

    • Rigid-Jointed (Frame): Must satisfy both external (reactions not concurrent/parallel) and internal (members properly connected) stability.

1.3 Structural Classification

  • Sway vs. Non-Sway:

    • Non-Sway: No significant horizontal displacement of joints under vertical loads (e.g., symmetric frame with symmetric vertical loading).

    • Sway: Significant horizontal displacement occurs (e.g., unsymmetric loading, frame with horizontal loads).

  • Pin-Jointed (Truss) vs. Rigidly Jointed (Frame):

    • Truss: Members carry only axial force (tension/compression). Joints are hinges.

    • Frame: Members can carry bending, shear, axial force. Joints are rigid, transferring moments.


2.0 ANALYSIS PRINCIPLES & THEOREMS

2.1 Principle of Virtual Work

  • Statement: For a structure in equilibrium, the total virtual work done by all external forces during any compatible virtual displacement is zero.

$$ \delta W_{ext} = \sum P_i \delta_i = 0 $$

  • Application to Deformable Bodies (Flexural Members):

$$ \delta = \int \frac{M m}{EI} dx $$

Where:

*   $\delta$ = deflection/displacement at point/direction of real load $P$.

*   $M$ = bending moment due to real load.

*   $m$ = bending moment due to a **unit virtual load** applied at the point & in the direction of desired $\delta$.

*   $EI$ = flexural rigidity (constant or variable).

[!TIP] Key: Always apply a unit load where you want the deflection. Use real $M$ diagram and unit-load $m$ diagram.

2.2 Maxwell's Reciprocal Deflection Theorem

  • Statement: The deflection at point A in the direction of a unit load applied at B is equal to the deflection at point B in the direction of a unit load applied at A.

$$ \delta_{A,B} = \delta_{B,A} $$

  • Significance: Deflection influence lines are symmetric. Derived from Betti's Theorem.

2.3 Betti's Theorem (Reciprocal Work Theorem)

  • Statement: For two systems of loads $$\displaystyle \{P_1\} $$ and $$\displaystyle \{P_2\} $$ acting on the same structure:

$$ \sum P_1 \delta_2 = \sum P_2 \delta_1 $$

Where $$\displaystyle \delta_1, \delta_2 $$ are displacements at load points due to the other load system.
  • Derivation of Maxwell's: Let System 1 have a single unit load at A. System 2 have a single unit load at B. Then:

$$ (1) \cdot \delta_{A,B} = (1) \cdot \delta_{B,A} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \delta_{A,B} = \delta_{B,A} $$

2.4 Castigliano's Theorems

  • First Theorem (Force → Displacement):

    • Statement: The partial derivative of the total strain energy $U$ with respect to any applied force $$\displaystyle P_i $$ gives the displacement $$\displaystyle \delta_i $$ in the direction of that force.

$$ \delta_i = \frac{\partial U}{\partial P_i} $$

*   **Application:** Beam deflection, redundant force calculation (if $U$ expressed in terms of redundant).
  • Second Theorem (Displacement → Force):

    • Statement: If the strain energy $U$ is expressed as a function of displacements, the partial derivative with respect to a displacement gives the corresponding force.

$$ P_i = \frac{\partial U}{\partial \delta_i} $$

*   **Application:** Finding reactions when a support settlement is known.

2.5 Strain Energy & Complementary Energy

  • Strain Energy ($U$): Energy stored in a structure due to deformation under load.

    • Axial: $$\displaystyle U = \int \frac{N^2}{2EA} dx $$

    • Bending: $$\displaystyle \boxed{U = \int \frac{M^2}{2EI} dx} $$ (Most Important)

    • Shear & Torsion forms also exist but less used in SA-I.

  • Complementary Energy ($$\displaystyle U^* $$): For linear elastic structures, $$\displaystyle U = U^* $$. Conceptually, it's energy expressed in terms of stresses.


3.0 INFLUENCE LINES

3.1 Definition & Importance

  • Influence Line Diagram (ILD): Graph showing the variation of a response function (reaction, shear, moment, member force) at a specific section of a structure as a unit concentrated load moves across it.

  • Difference from BMD: BMD shows values for a fixed load position along the entire span. ILD shows value at one specific section for all load positions.

  • Significance: Essential for analysis of structures under moving loads (bridges, cranes). Used to find maximum effect.

3.2 Construction Principles

  • Muller-Breslau Principle (Qualitative ILD):

    1. Remove the restraint corresponding to the desired function (e.g., for reaction at A, remove support A).

    2. Impose a unit displacement in the positive direction of that function (e.g., give support A a unit vertical displacement upward).

    3. The resulting displaced shape is the influence line for that function.

  • Analytical Method (Tabulation):

    • For Reaction: Use equilibrium. $$\displaystyle R_A = \frac{\text{Distance from load to opposite support}}{\text{Span}} $$.

    • For Shear: Sign convention: +ve shear causes clockwise rotation of left segment. ILD is two straight lines meeting at section.

    • For Moment: $$\displaystyle M = R_A \times x $$ (x = distance from A to section). ILD is two straight lines meeting at section, value = ± (lever arm).

3.3 Applications for Beams

  • Reaction ILD: Triangular/trapezoidal shape.

  • Shear Force ILD: Two lines, discontinuity at section. Value = ±1.

  • Bending Moment ILD: Two lines meeting at section. Max value at section = $$\displaystyle \frac{L}{4} $$ for simply supported beam under unit load at midspan.

3.4 Applications for Trusses

  • ILD for Member Force: Use Method of Sections or Joints as load moves. Cut through member, find force as function of load position 'x'.

  • UDL longer than span: Equivalent UDL (EUDL) concept. The ILD area under the load gives the member force.

$$ F = \text{Intensity} \times (\text{Area of ILD under load}) $$

  • Diagonal/Vertical Members: ILD shape depends on panel geometry. Often piecewise linear.

3.5 Moving Load Analysis

  • Single Concentrated Load: Place load at position of maximum ordinate of ILD.

  • Train of Loads: Position loads such that the leading load is at or near the peak of the ILD. Check all critical positions.

  • UDL (longer than span): Use EUDL. Maximum effect = $w \times (\text{Area of entire ILD})$.

[!TIP] Common Pitfall: Confusing ILD for shear sign. Remember: +ve shear ILD is positive when load is to the right of the section for a simply supported beam.


4.0 ARCH STRUCTURES

4.1 Classification

  • Material: Masonry, Steel, Concrete.

  • Shape: Parabolic (for UDL), Circular, Elliptical.

  • System: Three-hinged (statically determinate), Two-hinged, Fixed, Cantilever.

4.2 Three-Hinged Parabolic Arch

  • Geometry: Equation (origin at crown, y upward): $$\displaystyle \boxed{y = \frac{4h}{L^2} x^2} $$ where L=span, h=rise.

  • Horizontal Thrust (H): Found using conditions at crown hinge (M_c=0) or overall equilibrium.

    • UDL (w): $$\displaystyle \boxed{H = \frac{w L^2}{8h}} $$

    • Point Load (W) at distance 'a' from left support: Use moment equilibrium about crown hinge.

  • Support Reactions: Use $$\displaystyle \sum V=0 $$, $$\displaystyle \sum M=0 $$, and $H$ known. Vertical reactions: $$\displaystyle V_A, V_B $$.

  • Bending Moment, Shear, Normal Thrust at Section (distance x from left):

    • $$\displaystyle M_x = V_A \cdot x - H \cdot y - \text{moment of loads between A and section} $$

    • $$\displaystyle S_x $$ (shear) & $$\displaystyle N_x $$ (normal thrust) from resolution of forces along tangent/normal.

  • Eddy's Theorem: In a three-hinged arch, the bending moment at any section is proportional to the linear momentum (algebraic sum of moments of loads between section and one support about that section).

$$ M_x \propto \sum (P \cdot d) \text{ (from one support to section)} $$

4.3 Special Effects

  • Temperature Change: Causes additional horizontal thrust in two-hinged/fixed arches. $$\displaystyle \Delta H = \frac{\alpha \Delta T A E}{1 + \frac{L^2}{2 \pi^2 r^2} \frac{A}{I}} $$ (simplified). For three-hinged, no additional H (released at crown).

  • Rib Shortening: Axial compression in arch rib causes additional horizontal thrust (like temperature increase).

  • Support Settlement: Induces additional bending moments in all arches. For three-hinged, settlement of one support induces H and changes reactions.


5.0 CABLE STRUCTURES

5.1 Cable as a Structural Element

  • Definition: Flexible, inextensible member that can only resist tension along its tangent.

  • Assumptions:

    1. Flexibility (no bending stiffness).

    2. Loads applied at joints/nodes only.

    3. Tension constant in straight segment, varies along curve.

    4. Cable self-weight neglected or as UDL.

5.3 Analysis of Cables

  • Parabolic Cable (under UDL, horizontal components constant):

    • Equation: $$\displaystyle y = \frac{w}{2H} x^2 + \text{linear term} $$ (for symmetric, $$\displaystyle y = \frac{w}{2H} x^2 + c $$).

    • Horizontal Tension (H): Constant. For symmetric cable, $$\displaystyle H = \frac{w L^2}{8f} $$ where f = central sag.

    • Tension at Support: $$\displaystyle T = \sqrt{H^2 + V^2} $$, where $$\displaystyle V = wL/2 $$.

  • Catenary Cable (under self-weight, exact shape):

    • Equation: $$\displaystyle y = \frac{H}{w} \left( \cosh \frac{w x}{H} - 1 \right) $$.

    • Length: $$\displaystyle L_{cable} = \frac{2H}{w} \sinh \frac{w L}{2H} $$.

  • General (Concentrated Loads): Use equilibrium of each segment. Horizontal component $H$ is constant throughout. Solve from geometry & vertical equilibrium.


6.0 TRUSS ANALYSIS

6.1 Assumptions

  1. All members are pin-connected at joints.

  2. All loads & reactions act only at joints.

  3. Members are two-force members (axial force only, tension/compression).

  4. Self-weight neglected or lumped at joints.

  5. Small deformations, rigid connections.

6.2 Methods of Analysis

  • Method of Joints: Solve equilibrium ($$\displaystyle \sum F_x=0, \sum F_y=0 $$) at each joint sequentially. Start at joint with ≤2 unknowns.

  • Method of Sections: "Cut" the truss through no more than 3 members (or 2 if a support reaction is known). Apply $$\displaystyle \sum M=0 $$ to find one unknown, then $$\displaystyle \sum F_x, \sum F_y $$.

  • Advantage of Method of Sections: Directly finds force in specific interior member without solving entire truss.

6.3 Special Configurations

  • Zero-Force Members: Identify by inspection:

    • If only 2 non-collinear members meet at a joint with no external load, both are zero-force.

    • If 3 members meet, 2 collinear, and no external load, the non-collinear member is zero-force.

  • Warren Truss with Verticals: ILD for diagonals has positive and negative regions. Use method of sections as load moves.


7.0 BEAM & FRAME ANALYSIS METHODS

7.1 Continuous Beams

  • Slope Deflection Method:

    • Equation: $$\displaystyle M_{AB} = \frac{2EI}{L} (2\theta_A + \theta_B - 3\psi) + FEM_{AB} $$

    Where $$\displaystyle \psi = \frac{\Delta}{L} $$ (chord rotation due to sway).

    • Fixed-End Moments (FEM): Standard values for UDL, point load, etc.

    • Procedure: Write equations for each member, solve for unknown rotations $\theta$ & translations $\psi$ (sway). Use joint equilibrium & compatibility.

  • Moment Distribution Method:

    • Stiffness Factor (k): For member AB:

      • Far end fixed: $$\displaystyle k = \frac{4EI}{L} $$

      • Far end pinned: $$\displaystyle k = \frac{3EI}{L} $$

    • Distribution Factor (DF): $$\displaystyle DF_{AB} = \frac{k_{AB}}{\sum k_{Aj}} $$

    • Carry-Over Factor (COF): 0.5 (for prismatic member, far end fixed/pinned).

    • Procedure: Calculate FEM, apply DFs, carry over, repeat until balanced.

    • Sway: Can be handled by shear deflection (introducing a hypothetical force) or separate analysis.

  • Three-Moment Equation (Clapeyron's):

    • Standard Form (Uniform EI): For spans AB & BC:

$$ M_A L_{AB} + 2M_B (L_{AB}+L_{BC}) + M_C L_{BC} = -6 \left( \frac{A_{AB} \bar{x}_{AB}}{L_{AB}} + \frac{A_{BC} \bar{x}_{BC}}{L_{BC}} \right) $$

Where $A\bar{x}/L$ = moment of area of M/EI diagram about left end.

*   **Application:** Solve for unknown moments at interior supports. Draw BMD by superposition.

*   **Settled Supports:** Modify RHS to include effect of support settlements.

7.2 Fixed Beams & Propped Cantilevers

  • Fixed-End Moments: Memorize standard cases (UDL, point load at mid/end, couple).

  • Propped Cantilever: Use compatibility (deflection at prop = 0) with virtual work or slope deflection.

  • Support Settlement: Induces fixed-end moments even without external load. $$\displaystyle M_{induced} = \frac{6EI \Delta}{L^2} $$ for a cantilever settlement.

7.3 Portal Frames

  • Without Sway: Analyze like a beam (no horizontal displacement). Use slope deflection/moment distribution with $$\displaystyle \psi=0 $$.

  • With Sway: Horizontal load causes joint translation. Must consider chord rotation $\psi$. Solve simultaneously for rotations $\theta$ and sway $\psi$.

7.4 Column Analogy Method

  • Analogy: Bending moment $M$ in beam ↔ Axial thrust $P$ in column.

  • Procedure:

    1. Draw column load diagram (M/EI diagram of beam).

    2. Determine column reactions (these are beam fixed-end moments).

    3. For point loads/couples, apply them to column and find additional thrusts (additional moments).

  • Application: Fixed & continuous beams, especially with mixed loads.


8.0 SPECIAL TOPICS & APPLICATIONS (High-Frequency Numerical Types)

8.1 Deflection & Slope Relationships

  • Fundamental: $$\displaystyle \frac{d^2 y}{d x^2} = \frac{M}{EI} $$

  • Area-Moment Method: $$\displaystyle \theta_{AB} = \frac{1}{EI} \times (\text{Area of M diagram between A&B}) $$, $$\displaystyle \delta_B = \frac{1}{EI} \times (\text{Moment of area of M diagram about B}) $$.

  • Given Deflection/Slope to Find Length: For cantilever under UDL: $$\displaystyle \delta_{max} = \frac{wL^4}{8EI} $$, $$\displaystyle \theta_{free} = \frac{wL^3}{6EI} $$. Ratio $$\displaystyle \frac{\delta}{\theta} = \frac{L}{1.5} $$.

8.2 Influence Line for Specific Problems

  • Max Bending Moment at Section under Moving UDL: Occurs when UDL covers the section such that ILD area under load is max. For simply supported beam, max moment = $$\displaystyle wL^2/8 $$ at midspan.

  • Max +ve/-ve Moment under Moving Point Loads: Position loads to maximize algebraic sum of (load × ILD ordinate at load position).

8.3 Numerical Problem Types (Key Formulas)

  1. Horizontal Thrust in 3-Hinged Arch (UDL): $$\displaystyle \boxed{H = \frac{wL^2}{8h}} $$

  2. Horizontal Thrust (Point Load W at distance 'a' from left): $$\displaystyle H = \frac{W a b}{2 h L} $$ (a,b = distances from load to supports).

  3. Bending Moment in Arch: $$\displaystyle M_x = V_A x - H y - M_{loads} $$.

  4. Deflection using Virtual Work: $$\displaystyle \delta = \int \frac{M m}{EI} dx $$. For point load, use unit load method.

  5. Continuous Beam (Slope Deflection): Solve $$\displaystyle [K] \{\theta\} = \{-FEM\} $$ where $K$ is stiffness matrix.

  6. Cable Tension (Parabolic, UDL): $$\displaystyle H = \frac{wL^2}{8f} $$, $$\displaystyle T_{support} = \sqrt{H^2 + (wL/2)^2} $$.

  7. Cable Length (Parabolic approx): $$\displaystyle L_{cable} \approx L \left[1 + \frac{8f^2}{3L^2}\right] $$.

  8. Truss Member Force: Method of Joints: resolve at joint. Method of Sections: $$\displaystyle \sum M=0 $$ about point eliminating 2 unknowns.

[!TIP] Exam Strategy: For arches, always sketch the ILD for moment or thrust if needed. For continuous beams, clearly state FEMs and write slope-deflection equations before solving. For cables, draw free-body diagram of a segment to show constant H.


Final Note: This unit forms the foundation for all subsequent structural analysis. Master the theorems (Virtual Work, Castigliano, Maxwell/Betti) and influence lines thoroughly, as they are applied throughout the course. Practice degree of indeterminacy calculations and three-hinged arch problems extensively—they are almost guaranteed in every exam.

Go to where you left off?

Quick Add to Notes

Save questions, your own notes and screenshots into notes filed by unit. It takes a free account.

Create free account

Have an account? Log in