UNIT 4: Power Transmission and Distribution Systems
1. Power System Economics and Load Analysis
Load Curves and Load Duration Curves
-
Chronological Load Curve: Plot of load (kW or MW) versus time (hours/days/years). Shows variation of load with time.
-
Load Duration Curve (LDC): Load values arranged in descending order vs. time (percentage of total period). Obtained from chronological curve.
-
Utility: LDC directly gives:
-
Maximum Demand (peak of curve).
-
Load Factor = (Area under LDC) / (Area of rectangle with height = Max Demand).
-
Capacity Factor = (Area under LDC) / (Area of rectangle with height = Installed Capacity).
-
Economic Generation Planning: Helps in scheduling units (base, peak) and assessing reserve requirements.
-
[!TIP] Exam Tip: Be able to convert a given chronological table into an LDC and compute load factor/capacity factor.
Load Factors (Definitions & Interrelation)
| Factor | Definition | Formula | Impact on Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand Factor | Ratio of maximum demand to connected load. | $$\displaystyle k_d = \frac{P_{max}}{P_{connected}} $$ | Lower value means under-utilization of connected load. |
| Load Factor | Ratio of average load to maximum demand. | $$\displaystyle LF = \frac{P_{avg}}{P_{max}} = \frac{\text{Energy (kWh)} }{P_{max} \times T} $$ | Higher LF ➔ Lower cost/kWh (fixed costs spread over more units). |
| Diversity Factor | Ratio of sum of individual max demands to station max demand. | $$\displaystyle DF = \frac{\sum P_{max(i)}}{P_{max(station)}} $$ | Higher DF ➔ Lower P_{max(station)} ➔ Lower capital cost. |
| Utilization Factor | Ratio of maximum demand to installed capacity. | $$\displaystyle UF = \frac{P_{max}}{P_{installed}} $$ | Indicates spare capacity. |
| Plant Capacity Factor | Ratio of actual energy produced to max possible energy. | $$\displaystyle PCF = \frac{\text{Energy produced}}{P_{installed} \times T} $$ | Measures overall plant utilization. |
Key Relationship: $$\displaystyle P_{max(station)} = \frac{\sum P_{max(i)}}{DF} $$. A high DF reduces the required station capacity.
Interconnection of Power Stations
-
Advantages:
-
Economy: Shared reserve, optimal dispatch (economic load sharing), reduced installed capacity.
-
Reliability: Mutual aid during emergencies, improved load factor.
-
Efficiency: Can use larger, more efficient units.
-
-
Disadvantages:
-
High Initial Cost: Transmission lines, substations.
-
Complexity: Protection, control, stability issues.
-
Fault Propagation: Trouble in one area can cascade.
-
-
Control of Active & Reactive Power:
-
Active Power (kW): Controlled by governor settings (prime mover input). Increased mechanical power → increased electrical output. Tie-line power exchange is monitored and adjusted.
-
Reactive Power (kVAR): Controlled by excitation systems (field current). Increased excitation → increased voltage & reactive power output. Also via tap-changing transformers, shunt capacitors/reactors.
-
Economic Operation & Cost Analysis
-
Effect of LF & DF on Cost:
-
High LF → More energy sold → Fixed cost per unit ↓.
-
High DF → Lower P_{max} → Smaller/cheaper plant & equipment → Lower capital cost.
-
-
Annual Cost Components:
-
Fixed Cost: Interest, depreciation, taxes, insurance (independent of output).
-
Running Cost: Fuel, operation & maintenance (dependent on output).
-
-
Kelvin’s Law for Economic Conductor Size:
-
Statement: The most economical conductor size is that for which the annual cost of energy wasted equals the annual interest and depreciation on the capital cost of the conductor.
-
Derivation:
Let $k$ = cost per kg of conductor, $r$ = resistivity, $l$ = length, $a$ = cross-sectional area.
Capital Cost $$\displaystyle C_c = k \cdot a \cdot l $$.
Annual Interest & Depreciation $$\displaystyle = C_c \cdot (i + d) = k a l (i+d) $$.
Resistance $$\displaystyle R = \frac{\rho l}{a} $$.
Annual Energy Loss $$\displaystyle E_{loss} = I^2 R \times \text{hours} \times LF_{loss} $$.
Annual Cost of Loss $$\displaystyle C_l = \text{Cost per kWh} \times E_{loss} $$.
Total Annual Cost $$\displaystyle C = C_c + C_l $$.
For minimum $C$, $$\displaystyle \frac{dC}{da} = 0 \Rightarrow k l (i+d) - \frac{I^2 \rho l \cdot T \cdot LF_{loss}}{a^2} = 0 $$.
\boxed{a = \sqrt{\frac{I^2 \rho T \cdot LF_{loss}}{k (i+d)}}}
-
Limitations:
-
Ignores physical constraints (voltage drop, current density limits).
-
Interest/depreciation rates & energy cost are estimates.
-
Load factor for losses ($$\displaystyle LF_{loss} $$) is difficult to determine accurately.
-
Does not account for future load growth.
-
-
-
Effect of Transmission Voltage:
-
For same power $P$, $$\displaystyle I = P/(\sqrt{3} V \cos\phi) $$. Higher $V$ → Lower $I$.
-
Lower $I$ → Smaller conductor size (area $\propto I$) → Lower material cost.
-
Lower $$\displaystyle I^2R $$ loss → Higher efficiency.
-
Trade-off: Higher voltage requires more expensive insulators, towers, and substation equipment. There is an optimum voltage for a given power and distance.
-
Renewable and Non-Conventional Energy Sources
-
Classification:
-
Conventional: Thermal (coal, gas, nuclear), Hydro.
-
Non-Conventional / Renewable: Solar, Wind, Geothermal, Biomass, Tidal.
-
Distributed Generation (DG): Small-scale generation (solar panels, small wind) located near the load center.
-
-
Wind Power:
-
Power Developed: $$\displaystyle P = \frac{1}{2} \rho A C_p V_w^3 $$
-
$\rho$: Air density (kg/m³)
-
$$\displaystyle A = \pi R^2 $$: Swept area (m²)
-
$$\displaystyle C_p $$: Power coefficient (Betz limit = 0.593)
-
$$\displaystyle V_w $$: Wind velocity (m/s)
-
-
Horizontal Axis Wind Mill (HAWM): Axis parallel to ground. Higher efficiency, needs yaw mechanism, more common.
-
Vertical Axis Wind Mill (VAWM): Axis perpendicular to ground. Omnidirectional, no yaw needed, lower efficiency, higher mechanical stress.
-
2. Transmission Line Parameters
Resistance and Skin Effect
-
Skin Effect: Non-uniform current distribution at high AC frequencies. Current density is higher near the surface, reducing effective cross-section → AC resistance > DC resistance. Increases with frequency, conductor size, and material permeability.
-
Proximity Effect: Distortion of current distribution due to magnetic fields from adjacent conductors. Increases AC resistance further. Significant in bundled conductors and closely spaced cables.
Inductance Calculations
- Geometrical Mean Distance (GMD): For a group of conductors, it is the $$\displaystyle n^{th} $$ root of the product of all mutual distances between conductors.
$$GMD = \left( \prod_{i=1}^{n} \prod_{j=1, j\neq i}^{n} D_{ij} \right)^{1/n}$$
-
Geometrical Mean Radius (GMR) / Self-GMD: For a single conductor (stranded), it is the $$\displaystyle n^{th} $$ root of the product of all mutual distances between strands. For a round conductor of radius $r$: $GMR \approx 0.7788 r$. For a bundle of $n$ conductors with spacing $d$: $$\displaystyle GMR_{bundle} = (n \cdot d \cdot r)^{1/n} $$.
-
Single-Phase Two-Wire Line:
$$L = \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi} \ln\left(\frac{D}{GMR}\right) \text{ H/m}$$
where $D$ = distance between conductors.
-
Three-Phase Lines:
-
Symmetrically Spaced: $$\displaystyle L = \frac{\mu_0}{2\pi} \ln\left(\frac{GMD}{GMR}\right) $$.
-
Unsymmetrically Spaced: Transpose conductors to balance inductance. Equivalent $$\displaystyle GMD = \sqrt[3]{D_{12} D_{23} D_{31}} $$.
-
-
Bundled Conductors: Reduces inductance & capacitance, increases critical corona voltage. $$\displaystyle GMR_{phase} = (n \cdot d \cdot r)^{1/n} $$, $$\displaystyle GMD_{phase} = \sqrt[3]{D_{12} D_{23} D_{31}} $$ (where $$\displaystyle D_{ij} $$ are distances between bundle centers).
-
Transposition: Periodically exchanging conductor positions to make inductance & capacitance of all three phases equal. Necessary for unsymmetrical spacing.
Capacitance Calculations
- Single-Phase Transmission System:
$$C = \frac{\pi \epsilon_0}{\ln(D/r)} \text{ F/m}$$
(Assuming earth is infinitely far, effect negligible).
-
Three-Phase Lines:
-
Equilateral Spacing: $$\displaystyle C = \frac{2\pi \epsilon_0}{\ln(GMD/GMR)} $$.
-
Unsymmetrical Spacing: Use method of images or transposition to find equivalent $C$.
-
-
Effect of Earth: Increases capacitance. Using method of images, the presence of earth is equivalent to an image conductor below. The capacitance becomes:
$$C_{with earth} = \frac{2\pi \epsilon_0}{\ln\left(\frac{\sqrt{D_{12} D_{13} D_{23}}}{r \cdot \sqrt{D_{1'2'} D_{1'3'} D_{2'3'}}}\right)}$$
where primed distances are to image conductors.
- Single-Core Cable:
$$C = \frac{2\pi \epsilon}{\ln(r_i/r_c)} \text{ F/m}$$
where $$\displaystyle \epsilon = \epsilon_0 \epsilon_r $$, $$\displaystyle r_c $$ = conductor radius, $$\displaystyle r_i $$ = internal radius of sheath.
Conductor Selection and Economic Sizing
| System | Power Transmitted ($P$) | Voltage ($V$) | Current ($I$) | Conductor Resistance ($R$) | Conductor Area ($a \propto I$) | Losses ($$\displaystyle I^2R $$) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-Phase 2-Wire | $$\displaystyle P = 2 V I \cos\phi $$ | $V$ (phase-neutral) | $$\displaystyle I = P/(2V\cos\phi) $$ | $2R$ (loop) | $$\displaystyle a_{1\phi} \propto 1/V $$ | $$\displaystyle \propto 1/V^2 $$ |
| 3-Phase 3-Wire | $$\displaystyle P = \sqrt{3} V I \cos\phi $$ | $V$ (line-line) | $$\displaystyle I = P/(\sqrt{3} V \cos\phi) $$ | $R$ (per phase) | $$\displaystyle a_{3\phi} \propto 1/V $$ | $$\displaystyle \propto 1/V^2 $$ |
| 3-Phase 4-Wire | Same as 3-wire for phase loads | $V$ (line-line) | Same as 3-wire for phase loads | Same | Same for phase conductors | Same |
Conclusion: For same $P$, $V$, $\cos\phi$, and losses, 3-phase 3-wire requires least copper (only 3 conductors vs 4 in 4-wire, and lower current per conductor than single-phase).
3. Transmission Line Models and Performance
Short Transmission Lines (< 80 km)
-
Equivalent Circuit: Series impedance $$\displaystyle Z = R + jX $$ only. Shunt capacitance neglected.
-
Phasor Diagram: $$\displaystyle \vec{V}_s = \vec{V}_r + I \vec{Z} $$.
-
Voltage Regulation:
$$VR\% = \frac{|V_s|_{no-load} - |V_r|_{full-load}}{|V_r|_{full-load}} \times 100$$
Approximate formula (for lagging pf):
$$VR \approx \frac{I R \cos\phi_r + I X \sin\phi_r}{V_r} \times 100$$
- Transmission Efficiency:
$$\eta = \frac{P_r}{P_s} \times 100 = \frac{V_r I \cos\phi_r}{V_r I \cos\phi_r + I^2 R} \times 100$$
Medium Transmission Lines (80-250 km)
-
Nominal-T Model: Shunt admittance ($Y/2$) placed in middle, series impedance ($Z$) split equally.
-
Sending end: $$\displaystyle I_s = I_r + \frac{Y}{2} V_r $$
-
$$\displaystyle \vec{V}_s = \vec{V}_r + I_r Z + \frac{Y}{2} V_r \cdot \frac{Z}{2} $$ (approx: $$\displaystyle \vec{V}_s = \vec{V}_r + I_r Z + \frac{Y}{2} V_r $$)
-
-
Nominal-π Model: Shunt admittance split ($Y/2$ at each end), series impedance ($Z$) in middle.
-
$$\displaystyle I_s = I_r + \frac{Y}{2} V_s + \frac{Y}{2} V_r $$
-
$$\displaystyle \vec{V}_s = \vec{V}_r + I_r Z $$
-
-
Generalized Circuit Constants (ABCD Parameters):
For π-model:
$$A = D = 1 + \frac{YZ}{2}, \quad B = Z, \quad C = Y\left(1 + \frac{YZ}{4}\right) \approx Y$$
Relations: $$\displaystyle V_s = A V_r + B I_r $$, $$\displaystyle I_s = C V_r + D I_r $$.
-
Sending End Calculations: Given $$\displaystyle V_r $$, $$\displaystyle I_r $$, $$\displaystyle \phi_r $$, and line parameters, find $$\displaystyle V_s $$, $$\displaystyle I_s $$, $$\displaystyle P_s $$, $$\displaystyle pf_s $$ using ABCD constants.
-
Power Circle Diagram:
-
Construction: Plot $$\displaystyle P_r $$ vs $$\displaystyle Q_r $$ or $$\displaystyle P_s $$ vs $$\displaystyle Q_s $$ for constant $$\displaystyle |V_r| $$ or $$\displaystyle |V_s| $$. Circle equation derived from $$\displaystyle |V_s|^2 = |A V_r + B I_r|^2 $$.
-
Interpretation: Shows regions of power transfer for given voltages, limits for stability ($$\displaystyle dP_s/d\delta $$), and reactive power requirements.
-
Long Transmission Lines (> 250 km)
- Rigorous Solution: Use telegrapher's equation. Voltage & current are traveling waves.
$$\frac{\partial^2 V}{\partial x^2} = Z Y V, \quad \frac{\partial^2 I}{\partial x^2} = Z Y I$$
Solution: $$\displaystyle V = V_1 e^{-\gamma x} + V_2 e^{\gamma x} $$, $$\displaystyle I = \frac{V_1}{Z_c} e^{-\gamma x} - \frac{V_2}{Z_c} e^{\gamma x} $$
where **Propagation constant** $$\displaystyle \gamma = \sqrt{ZY} = \alpha + j\beta $$, **Surge impedance** $$\displaystyle Z_c = \sqrt{Z/Y} $$.
-
Interpretation:
-
$$\displaystyle e^{-\gamma x} $$: Surge traveling toward receiving end (attenuated & phase-shifted).
-
$$\displaystyle e^{\gamma x} $$: Surge traveling toward sending end.
-
For lossless line ($$\displaystyle \alpha=0 $$): Pure sinusoid propagation, $$\displaystyle Z_c $$ is real.
-
-
Ferranti Effect: Voltage rise at the receiving end of a long, lightly-loaded line compared to sending end. Caused by the capacitive charging current flowing through the line inductance ($$\displaystyle I_c jX $$ voltage drop adds to $$\displaystyle V_r $$). More pronounced in cables and EHV/UHV lines.
-
Tuned Power Line: A long line designed so that its reactance is tuned (resonates) with its shunt capacitance at the operating frequency. Condition: $$\displaystyle X = 1/(\omega C) $$ or $$\displaystyle X \cdot \omega C = 1 $$. Results in $$\displaystyle Z_c = \infty $$ and $$\displaystyle \gamma = \sqrt{ZY} \approx \sqrt{jX \cdot j\omega C} = \sqrt{-\omega^2 X C} $$ → purely real? Actually, for tuned line, $$\displaystyle B = \omega C $$, $$\displaystyle X = 1/(\omega C) $$ so $$\displaystyle XY = -1 $$, $$\displaystyle \gamma = j\alpha $$? Careful: Tuned line means $$\displaystyle X = 1/(\omega C) $$ → $$\displaystyle Z = jX $$, $$\displaystyle Y = j\omega C $$, so $$\displaystyle ZY = -1 $$, $$\displaystyle \gamma = \sqrt{-1} = j $$, $$\displaystyle \alpha=0 $$, $$\displaystyle \beta=1 $$. The surge impedance $$\displaystyle Z_c = \sqrt{jX / j\omega C} = \sqrt{X / \omega C} = \sqrt{1/(\omega^2 C^2)} = 1/(\omega C) $$, finite. The key is that the line behaves like a pure resistance? Actually, a tuned line has constant voltage magnitude along its length. It's used in HVDC converter stations and some AC applications for power flow control.
Voltage Control Methods
-
Overview:
-
Tap-Changing Transformers: On-load (OLTC) or off-load. Adjusts $V$ ratio.
-
Shunt Compensation: Shunt capacitors (raise voltage), shunt reactors (lower voltage).
-
Series Compensation: Series capacitors (reduce line reactance, increase power transfer, improve stability).
-
Synchronous Condensers: Over-excited synchronous motor (acts as capacitor), under-excited (acts as inductor).
-
Static VAR Compensators (SVC)/STATCOM: Fast-acting power electronics.
-
-
Detailed Example: Shunt Capacitors:
-
Purpose: Compensate for lagging reactive power of inductive loads/lines.
-
Connection: Delta or wye at substation or along the line.
-
Effect: Supplies leading current, reducing net reactive power flow from source → voltage rise at point of connection.
-
Calculation: Required $$\displaystyle Q_c = P (\tan\phi_{initial} - \tan\phi_{desired}) $$.
-
4. Mechanical Design of Overhead Lines
Sag and Tension Calculations (Level Supports)
-
Shape: Parabolic approximation (valid for sag << span). Exact shape is catenary.
-
Derivation:
Let $L$ = span length, $w$ = weight per unit length, $$\displaystyle T_m $$ = tension at lowest point (horizontal tension), $x$ = horizontal distance from lowest point, $y$ = vertical sag at $x$.
Equilibrium: $$\displaystyle T_m \frac{d^2 y}{dx^2} = w \sqrt{1 + (dy/dx)^2} \approx w $$ (for small sag).
Integrating: $$\displaystyle \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{w}{T_m} x $$, $$\displaystyle y = \frac{w}{2T_m} x^2 $$.
At support ($$\displaystyle x = L/2 $$, $$\displaystyle y = S $$): $$\displaystyle S = \frac{w L^2}{8 T_m} $$.
\boxed{S = \frac{w L^2}{8 T_m}} \quad \text{and} \quad \boxed{T_m = \frac{w L^2}{8 S}}
Total tension at support: $$\displaystyle T_s = \sqrt{T_m^2 + (w L/2)^2} \approx T_m + \frac{w^2 L^2}{8 T_m} $$.
-
Effect of Wind and Ice Loading:
-
Total weight per unit length becomes: $$\displaystyle w' = \sqrt{(w + w_{ice})^2 + (w_{wind})^2} $$
-
where $$\displaystyle w_{ice} = \text{volume of ice per unit length} \times \text{density of ice} $$.
-
Wind load $$\displaystyle w_{wind} = \text{pressure} \times \text{projected diameter} $$ (conductor dia + 2×ice thickness).
-
Sag $$\displaystyle S' = \frac{w' L^2}{8 T_m} $$ (use maximum tension $$\displaystyle T_m $$ from safety criteria).
-
Maximum Sag occurs at the point of maximum $w'$ and maximum temperature (minimum $$\displaystyle T_m $$).
-
Sag Templates and String Charts
-
Sag Template: A full-scale drawing of the sag curve for a specific conductor, span, tension, and temperature. Used on profile drawings to:
-
Check clearance at any point.
-
Determine required support height for given terrain.
-
Find stringing tension for a given clearance.
-
-
String Chart: Graph of tension vs. temperature for a fixed span and initial condition. Shows how tension changes with temperature (thermal expansion). Used to find stringing tension for a given temperature to achieve desired sag at maximum temperature.
-
Difference: Sag template is a spatial tool (sag vs. distance). String chart is a tension-temperature relationship tool.
Line Supports and Structures
| Support Type | Typical Voltage | Span Length | Features / Suitability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wooden Poles | LT Distribution (< 11 kV) | Short (< 50 m) | Cheap, insulating, low strength. |
| Steel Poles | LT/HT Distribution (11-33 kV) | Medium | Stronger, longer life than wood. |
| H-Frame/Steel Towers | Sub-Transmission (33-132 kV) | Medium-Long | Two poles with cross-arm. |
| Tower Structures | EHV/Transmission (> 132 kV) | Long (> 300 m) | Self-supporting, various types (Suspension, Tension, Transposition). Designed for heavy loads, wind, ice. |
5. Insulators and Insulation Coordination
Types of Insulators (with Construction)
| Type | Construction | Application | Sketch Key Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pin Type | Single porcelain/glass shell, pin cemented. | LT distribution (< 33 kV). | Pin mounted on cross-arm. |
| Suspension Type | Series of discs (cap & pin) linked by hardware. | HT/EHV transmission. | Hangs from cross-arm, flexible. |
| Strain Type | Similar to suspension but stronger, for dead-ends. | Heavy tension points, river crossings. | Reinforced, often with guy wires. |
| Shackle Type | Small, for LT, can be clamped directly. | LT distribution, service connections. | No pin, clamped to pole. |
- Advantage of Suspension for HV: Economical (cheaper discs), flexible (reduces mechanical stress), easy to replace single disc, can be used for any voltage by adding discs.
Voltage Distribution in Insulator Strings
-
Capacitance Model:
-
$C$: Self-capacitance (capacitance to earth) of each unit.
-
$$\displaystyle C_1 $$: Pin-to-earth (or cap-to-earth) capacitance of each unit (due to metal fittings).
-
Usually $$\displaystyle C_1 = mC $$, where $m \approx 0.1 - 0.2$.
-
-
Derivation (for $n$ units):
Let $$\displaystyle V_1, V_2, ..., V_n $$ be voltages across units from top (line side) to bottom (earth side).
By Kirchhoff's current law at each node (except ends):
$$C(V_1 - V_2) + mC V_1 = C(V_2 - V_3) + mC V_2 \quad \Rightarrow \quad V_2 = \frac{1}{1+m} V_1 + \frac{m}{1+m} V_3$$
Solving recursively gives: $$\displaystyle V_k = V_1 \left[ \frac{\sinh((n-k)\theta)}{\sinh(n\theta)} \right] $$ where $$\displaystyle \cosh\theta = 1 + 2m $$.
For $$\displaystyle m << 1 $$, $\theta \approx \sqrt{2m}$.
**Top unit voltage** is highest.
- String Efficiency:
$$\eta_{string} = \frac{\text{Voltage across string}}{\sum \text{Voltage across each unit}} \times 100 = \frac{V_1 + V_2 + ... + V_n}{n \cdot V_n} \times 100$$
(Often defined as $$\displaystyle V_{line} / (n \cdot V_{bottom}) $$ where $$\displaystyle V_{bottom} $$ is voltage on lowest unit).
\boxed{\eta_{string} = \frac{n}{1 + (n-1)m} \times 100\%} \quad (\text{for } m<<1, \text{ approximate})
Methods to Improve String Efficiency
-
Grading of Insulator Units:
-
Use discs with different capacitances (e.g., larger diameter for lower units).
-
Aim: Make voltage distribution uniform. $$\displaystyle C_{top} < C_{bottom} $$.
-
Capacitance Grading: Vary disc size.
-
Intersheath Grading: Insert metallic sheaths between discs (rarely used).
-
-
Guard Rings (Corona Rings):
-
Large diameter ring connected to top of string and to tower arm.
-
Increases capacitance from top units to earth ($m$ increases for top units), equalizing voltage distribution.
-
Also reduces corona on hardware.
-
Insulator Testing
-
Flash-Over Voltage Testing:
-
Apply increasing AC voltage to insulator string until flash-over occurs.
-
Record voltage at flash-over.
-
Repeat to get average (dry, wet conditions specified).
-
Critical Flash-Over Voltage (CFOV): Voltage at which flash-over probability is high.
-
Withstand Voltage: Voltage the insulator can sustain for a specified time without flash-over.
-
6. Underground Cables
Construction and Types
-
Single-Core Cable: One conductor + insulation + sheath. Used for high voltage.
-
Multi-Core Cable: 3 or 4 cores in common sheath. Used for distribution (3-phase 4-wire).
-
Insulation Materials:
-
Paper (impregnated with oil): Traditional for HV.
-
Rubber (natural/synthetic): Flexible, LT.
-
PVC: General purpose, good mechanical properties.
-
XLPE (Cross-Linked Polyethylene): Modern, high dielectric strength, high temperature rating.
-
-
Sheath: Lead or aluminum for moisture/chemical protection.
Capacitance and Insulation Resistance
-
Capacitance (single-core, cylindrical): $$\displaystyle C = \frac{2\pi \epsilon}{\ln(r_i/r_c)} $$ F/km.
- High capacitance → high charging current → limitation for long cables.
-
Insulation Resistance: $$\displaystyle R_{ins} = \frac{\rho_l \ln(r_i/r_c)}{2\pi l} $$ (for radial geometry). Decreases with length.
Dielectric Stress in Cables
- Expression (radial, cylindrical symmetry):
$$E(r) = \frac{V}{r \ln(r_i/r_c)} \quad \text{(for r_c ≤ r ≤ r_i)}$$
where $V$ = conductor voltage (to sheath), $$\displaystyle r_c $$ = conductor radius, $$\displaystyle r_i $$ = insulation outer radius.
- Maximum Stress: At conductor surface ($$\displaystyle r = r_c $$).
$$E_{max} = \frac{V}{r_c \ln(r_i/r_c)}$$
- Minimum Stress: At insulation outer surface ($$\displaystyle r = r_i $$).
$$E_{min} = \frac{V}{r_i \ln(r_i/r_c)}$$
-
Calculation:
Given $$\displaystyle E_{max} $$ (material limit), $$\displaystyle r_c $$, find $$\displaystyle r_i $$: $$\displaystyle r_i = r_c e^{V/(r_c E_{max})} $$.
Operating voltage $V$ is phase-neutral for single-core.
Grading of Cables
-
Capacitance Grading (Intersheath Grading):
-
Use multiple insulation layers of different $$\displaystyle \epsilon_r $$.
-
Place high $$\displaystyle \epsilon_r $$ material near conductor (where $E$ is high), low $$\displaystyle \epsilon_r $$ outside.
-
Homogeneous Dielectric: $E \propto 1/r$.
-
Graded Dielectric: $E$ becomes more uniform.
-
-
Inter-sheath Grading: Insert thin metallic intersheaths at specific potentials between insulation layers. Each layer operates at lower voltage gradient.
Comparison: Overhead Lines vs. Underground Cables
| Feature | Overhead Lines | Underground Cables |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Low (per km) | Very high (installation, insulation) |
| Installation | Easy, quick | Difficult, time-consuming |
| Faults | More (weather, pollution) | Less, but hard to locate/repair |
| Appearance | Visible, requires ROW | Hidden, aesthetically better |
| Voltage Drop | Low inductance, moderate capacitance | Very high capacitance (charging current) |
| Suitable For | Rural, long distance, high voltage | Urban, congested areas, submarine |
7. Distribution Systems and Substations
Types of Distribution Systems
| System | Description | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Radial | Single source, feeders radiate out. | Simple, cheap, easy protection. | Poor reliability (single point failure). |
| Ring Main | Feeder forms a loop, supply from both ends. | Better reliability, voltage regulation. | More complex protection, higher cost. |
| Interconnected | Multiple interconnections, meshed. | Highest reliability, flexibility. | Most complex, expensive, difficult protection. |
Three-Phase Systems: 3-Wire vs. 4-Wire
-
Transmission (3-Wire): Only line conductors. No neutral needed as loads are balanced (or single-phase loads not connected). Saves one conductor (25% saving in copper for same voltage between phases).
-
Distribution (4-Wire): Includes neutral conductor. Allows:
-
Single-phase loads (phase-to-neutral, 230 V) for domestic/commercial.
-
Three-phase loads (phase-to-phase, 415 V) for industrial.
-
Neutral carries unbalanced current & provides path for zero-sequence currents.
-
-
Copper Efficiency Comparison:
-
For same power $P$, voltage between phases $$\displaystyle V_L $$, power factor $\cos\phi$, and losses:
-
3-Wire System: $$\displaystyle I = P/(\sqrt{3} V_L \cos\phi) $$. Conductor area $$\displaystyle a_{3w} \propto I $$.
-
4-Wire System: For balanced 3-phase load, same $I$ per phase. But neutral may carry some current. Roughly, 4-wire requires about 33% more copper than 3-wire for same phase-to-phase voltage and balanced 3-phase load. The trade-off is the ability to serve single-phase loads.
-
Substation Equipment and Layout (Single Line Diagram)
-
Main Equipment:
-
Power Transformer: Steps voltage up/down.
-
Circuit Breaker (CB): Makes/breaks normal & fault currents.
-
Isolator/Disconnecting Switch: Isolates equipment for maintenance (no load breaking).
-
Current Transformer (CT): Steps down current for metering/protection.
-
Potential Transformer (PT): Steps down voltage for metering/protection.
-
Lightning Arrester: Protects against overvoltages (lightning, switching).
-
Capacitor Bank: For power factor correction.
-
Bus Bars: Collect and distribute power.
-
Relays & Control Panels: Protection and control logic.
-
-
Typical SLD: Shows incoming lines → Isolators → CTs → CB → Transformer → Bus Bars → Outgoing CBs/Isolators → feeders. All major equipment represented by standard symbols.
Bus Bar Arrangements
| Arrangement | Description | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Bus Bar | All circuits connected to one bus. | Simple, cheap, minimal CBs. | Bus fault → total shutdown. Maintenance difficult. |
| Single Bus with Sectionalization | Bus split by a CB or isolator. | Sectional fault → partial shutdown. Can isolate section for maintenance. | More CBs, protection complex. |
| Double Bus Bar | Two parallel buses, each circuit connected to both via CBs. | One bus can be maintained without interruption. High reliability. | Expensive (2x bus, more CBs), complex operation. |
| Sectionalized Double Bus | Double bus with sectional CBs. | Very high reliability & flexibility. | Most expensive, most complex. |
| Ring Main | Bus arranged in ring, often with sectionalizing. | Alternate supply paths, good reliability. | Protection coordination complex. |
8. Special Topics and Comparative Studies
Bundle Conductors vs Double Circuit Lines
| Feature | Bundle Conductors (2+ per phase) | Double Circuit Line (2 separate 3-phase circuits) |
|---|---|---|
| Configuration | Multiple conductors per phase on same tower. | Two complete 3-phase circuits on same tower. |
| Inductance | Lower (due to larger GMR). | Lower than single circuit, but higher than equivalent bundle? Actually, double circuit has mutual inductance between circuits, net inductance per phase can be lower. |
| Capacitance | Higher (smaller GMD to other phases? Actually, bundling increases GMD to other phases? Wait: For same phase spacing, bundling increases GMR → decreases inductance, but for capacitance, $C \propto 1/\ln(GMD/GMR)$. Increasing GMR increases denominator → decreases capacitance? Let's think: $C \propto 1/\ln(GMD/GMR)$. If GMR increases (bundle), $\ln(GMD/GMR)$ decreases → $C$ increases. Yes, capacitance increases. | Higher than single circuit due to presence of second circuit (mutual capacitance). |
| Corona & RI | Better (larger effective diameter → higher critical voltage). | Similar benefit from larger total conductor diameter per circuit? But separate circuits don't bundle. |
| Reliability | Single circuit failure → total loss of that circuit. | One circuit can be maintained/outaged, other supplies. Higher reliability. |
| Cost & Complexity | More complex stringing, higher tower cost (wider). | Much taller/wider towers, more insulators, hardware. Higher cost. |
| Application | EHV/UHV (400 kV+) to reduce losses & improve stability. | High reliability required routes, or to increase transfer capacity on existing corridor. |
Air-Insulated Substations (AIS) vs Gas-Insulated Substations (GIS)
| Feature | AIS | GIS |
|---|---|---|
| Insulation | Air (atmospheric). | SF₆ gas (high dielectric strength). |
| Footprint | Large (clearances needed). | Very Small (1/10th of AIS). |
| Cost | Lower equipment cost, higher land cost. | Higher equipment cost, lower land cost. |
| Maintenance | Simple, visual inspection. | Less frequent, but gas monitoring needed. |
| Environmental | Visible, affected by pollution, birds. | Enclosed, immune to pollution, salt fog. |
| Reliability | Lower (exposed to weather, faults). | Higher (encapsulated, less faults). |
| Application | Rural, areas with cheap land. | Urban, industrial, coastal, polluted areas, space-constrained. |
Problems in Modern Large Interconnected Power Systems
-
Stability Issues: Angle stability (transient, steady-state), voltage stability. Complex dynamics.
-
Frequency Control: Need for automatic generation control (AGC) across regions.
-
Protection Challenges: Faults affect large areas, need coordinated relaying, distance protection with communication.
-
Power Flow Control: Congestion management, loop flows.
-
Blackouts: Cascading failures, need for wide-area monitoring (WAMS) and control.
-
Renewable Integration: Variability, uncertainty, inverter-based resources reducing inertia.
-
Market Operations: Transmission congestion management, locational marginal pricing (LMP).
Tuned Power Lines (Brief)
-
A long transmission line where the inductive reactance ($X$) is tuned to the capacitive reactance ($1/\omega C$) such that $$\displaystyle X \cdot \omega C = 1 $$.
-
Characteristics:
-
Surge impedance $$\displaystyle Z_c = \sqrt{X / \omega C} = 1/(\omega C) $$ (pure resistive).
-
Propagation constant $$\displaystyle \gamma = \sqrt{ZY} = \sqrt{jX \cdot j\omega C} = \sqrt{-\omega^2 X C} = j \omega \sqrt{X C} $$? Wait: $$\displaystyle ZY = (jX)(j\omega C) = -\omega^2 X C $$. If $$\displaystyle X = 1/(\omega C) $$, then $$\displaystyle ZY = -1 $$, $$\displaystyle \gamma = \sqrt{-1} = j $$. So $$\displaystyle \alpha=0 $$, $$\displaystyle \beta=1 $$ rad/km. No attenuation, only phase shift.
-
Voltage magnitude remains constant along the line.
-
-
Application: Used in HVDC converter stations (as AC filter/tuned filter) and some special AC applications for power flow control.
Isolated vs Interconnected Power Systems
| Aspect | Isolated System | Interconnected System |
|---|---|---|
| Reserve Capacity | High (each station has own spinning reserve). | Low (shared reserve, mutual assistance). |
| Economy | Poor (smaller units, less optimal dispatch). | Better (economical load sharing, use of large efficient units). |
| Reliability | Low (single station failure causes blackout). | High (alternative sources, redundancy). |
| Stability | Easier to control (smaller). | Difficult (complex dynamics, oscillations). |
| Capital Cost | Lower initial (no interconnectors). | Higher (transmission links, substations). |
| Operational Flexibility | Low. | High (power can flow as needed). |
| Frequency Control | Simple, local. | Complex, requires AGC & coordination. |